Here We Are
Our college spends more each year than it brings in, and doing a little less of the same thing will not fix that. This section explains why in plain terms, and why the answer depends on all of us.
Fewer students, more choices
The number of Americans finishing high school peaked in 2025 at roughly 3.8 to 3.9 million. It is projected to fall about 13 percent by 2041, and 38 states will have fewer graduates in 2041 than in 2023. The Northeast and Midwest have already started to decline.
Fewer students means every college competes harder for each one. The most common response is a bigger scholarship. Private colleges now give back an average of about 57 percent of sticker tuition to first-year students as their own aid, a record. Each point of discount is money the college never collects.
Even after the decline, more than three million people will finish high school every year. Millions of adults want a degree or a new skill. They will all go somewhere. How do we make sure it is here?
What the market wants decides what we can sell
Think of a concert hall with empty seats. If people do not want to hear the program, a bigger poster will not fill the hall. Better marketing tells more people what we offer. It cannot make them want it.
Business people call this product/market fit: offering something enough people want, at a price they will pay, that costs less to deliver than it brings in. When a college has a fit problem, the offering has to change: what we teach, how, when, where, for whom and at what price.
Why the people closest to the college should not set the direction
Current students chose us. Faculty built what we offer. Both are the people for whom the current college already works. That makes them the right people to tell us what must not be lost, and the wrong people to tell us what the students who are not choosing us want.
This workbook asks faculty and students to do real work: supply facts, propose ideas, test them, design the new offering and deliver it. The direction itself comes from evidence about the students we are trying to reach.
Why we are sharing more than usual
Colleges in trouble often keep the numbers quiet, hope next year's class is bigger and protect the identity they have. Each of those feels prudent. Together they use up the time and money needed to change.
Plans also fail when leaders decide in a small room, agree too quickly and avoid being wrong in public. The cure is more people looking at the same facts, and someone whose job is to say the plan will not work.
The Six Ideas That Explain Every College Budget
You do not need a business degree to use them, and you do need all six to judge any idea for the college's future.
1. Sticker Price & Net Price
The sticker price is the published tuition. Almost no one pays it. The net price is what a student actually pays after the college's own scholarships and grants.
2. Discount Rate
The share of sticker tuition the college gives back as its own aid. If tuition is $50,000 and the average student receives $27,500 in college-funded aid, the discount rate is 55%.
3. Net Tuition Revenue
Students times net price. This is the money that pays salaries. A college can enroll more students and still collect less money if it discounts more to get them.
4. Cost Per Student
Total operating spending divided by students. Most of that cost is fixed in the short run: buildings, debt, most salaries.
5. Contribution
What one more student or program brings in minus the costs that go away if it goes away. A program with negative contribution makes the gap bigger every year it runs.
6. Cash Runway
How many months the college can pay its bills from cash and investments it is allowed to spend, at its current rate of loss. Runway is the clock.
A Worked Example
This is an imaginary college. You will replace every number with yours in Phase 1.
| Students | 1,500 | Fall enrollment |
| Sticker tuition | $50,000 | Published price |
| Discount rate | 55% | College aid ÷ sticker tuition |
| Net tuition per student | $22,500 | $50,000 × (1 − 0.55) |
| Housing, dining & other net revenue | $8,000 | After costs of running housing and dining |
| Net revenue per student | $30,500 | $22,500 + $8,000 |
| Cost per student | $38,000 | Total spending ÷ students |
| Gap per student | −$7,500 | $38,000 − $30,500 |
| Annual gap | −$11.25 million | $7,500 × 1,500 |
Discounting more to fill seats can make the gap worse. Raise the discount rate from 55% to 60% and each student brings in $2,500 less. Across 1,500 students that is $3.75 million a year.
Three Rules for the Whole Year
- Numbers first, opinions second. Every idea gets tested against the same worksheets.
- The people who are here help build the future, and the people who are not here tell us what it must be. Prospective students set the direction.
- Change moves at the speed of trust. Share more than feels comfortable, on a schedule, and never share a number you will have to take back.
Who Does What
| PRES | President | Own the process. Fill in Phase 1 with the CFO. |
| CFO | Chief Financial Officer | Supply every number in Phase 1, honestly and on time. |
| BOARD | Trustees | Set decision rights and stopping rules. Appoint the red team. |
| CABINET | Senior Leaders | Run the market research and the working teams. |
| FACULTY | Faculty & Academic Staff | Supply program facts and ideas. Design and teach the pilot. |
| STUDENTS | Current Students | Test ideas, help with research, tell us what must not be lost. |
Phase 1: Face the Numbers
By day 30, the president and CFO produce one page that states the size of the gap, the months of runway and the enrollment the college can expect.
Gather First
- Five to ten years of audited financial statements
- Five to ten years of IRS Form 990 filings
- Five to ten years of fall enrollment, entering class, yield and retention (IPEDS reports)
- Each year's original budget beside actual results
- Current debt schedule and loan covenants
- Revenue and direct cost by program and by school
The Gap Calculator
Enter your numbers. The workbook computes the rest.
| Line | Item | Your Number |
|---|---|---|
| A | Students enrolled this fall | |
| — | Sticker tuition ($) | |
| — | Discount rate (%) | |
| — | Net tuition per student ($) | |
| — | Housing, dining & other net revenue per student ($) | |
| B | Net revenue per student ($) | |
| C | Student revenue ($) | |
| D | Other dependable revenue ($) | |
| E | Total operating spending ($) | |
| F | Annual gap ($) | |
| G | Gap per student ($) | |
| H | Cost that goes away with one fewer student ($) | |
| I | Contribution of one more student ($) | |
| J | Added students needed to close the gap | |
| K | Effect of a one-point rise in discount rate ($) |
The Runway Calculator
| Line | Item | Your Number |
|---|---|---|
| R1 | Unrestricted cash & investments available in 90 days ($) | |
| R2 | Amount required for loan covenants / reserves ($) | |
| R3 | Usable cash ($) | |
| R4 | Average monthly cash loss ($) | |
| R5 | Months of runway | |
| R6 | Months a full transition will take | |
| R7 | Cushion (months) |
Decision Rights, Stopping Rules & Red Team
Stopping Rules
A stopping rule is a promise made in advance: if this measure crosses this line, we will take this action. The board votes on these before any idea is on the table.
| Measure | Our Line | If crossed, we will... | How Often |
|---|---|---|---|
| Months of runway | Monthly | ||
| Total transition losses ($) | Quarterly | ||
| First-year deposits by May 1 | Weekly in spring | ||
| Net revenue per student ($) | Each term | ||
| First-to-second-year retention (%) | Each fall | ||
| Pilot deposits vs. target | At deadline |
Red Team Checklist
- Three to five people, named by the board
- At least one with finance expertise from outside the college
- At least one from outside higher education
- No one who wrote the plan under review
- Access to the same data as the cabinet
The president speaks last in every decision meeting. Run a premortem: before approving a plan, everyone writes privately why it failed two years from now. Write forecasts down with dates and authors. Reward the bad news.
Phase 2: Ask the People Who Did Not Choose Us
By day 60, enrollment leadership delivers a demand brief built on professional research with people who looked at the college and went elsewhere, and people who never looked. Their answers set the direction.
Who to Talk To
| Group | Why They Matter | Minimum |
|---|---|---|
| Admitted students who enrolled elsewhere | They wanted us enough to apply and still said no. Their reasons are the most useful data we have. | 30 interviews + survey |
| People who inquired and never applied | They looked and lost interest | 20 interviews |
| People who never considered us | The students we need and do not reach | 30 interviews |
| Current students | What we do well and must protect | 20 interviews |
| Employers and community partners | What work students can count on | 10 interviews |
Interview Guide
- Tell me how you decided where to go. What were the finalists?
- What did the place you chose offer that the others did not?
- What did you think of us? Where did that impression come from?
- What did it cost you in the end, after aid? How much did price matter?
- What would have to be true for you to choose a college like ours?
- If we offered [describe an idea in one sentence], would you have considered it?
- What do you want to be able to do in five years that college should help with?
Demand Evidence Worksheet
| What They Want | Who Said It | How Many | What They Chose Instead | Price They'd Pay |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Prompts for Faculty
Which students outside our current pool could your field serve well, and how would they study?
Which courses could be shared across programs, or with a partner college?
What does your program do that students cannot get cheaper or closer to home?
If your program had to double enrollment or halve its cost in three years, what would you change first?
Demand Brief Deliverable (Due Day 60)
- The three groups of students most likely to choose us, and how many are within reach
- The top reasons admitted students went elsewhere, with counts
- The net price each group will pay
- What current students say we must not lose
- Employer commitments in writing
Phase 3: Design and Test Ideas
By day 120, working teams turn the strongest ideas into one-page A3 proposals that the red team has tried to break and the CFO has priced. Anyone can submit an idea.
Step 1: The Idea Card
One idea per card. Keep it to one page.
Step 2: The Screen
An idea moves to an A3 team only if the answer to all six is yes.
- We have evidence of demand from people who are not current students
- At full size it closes a meaningful percent of the annual gap within three years
- We can test it with real applications and deposits within twelve months
- We have, or can affordably get, the people and space to deliver it
- It does not weaken a program or school that earns a real surplus
Step 3: The Strategy A3 Proposal
| 1. Background | |
| 2. Current State | |
| 3. Target State | |
| 4. Gap & Root Cause | |
| 5. Countermeasures | |
| 6. Test Plan | |
| 7. Follow-up |
Step 4: Three Alternatives for the Board
| A: Redesigned College | B: Smaller College | C: Partnership / Exit | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Students served | |||
| Enrollment in year five | |||
| Net revenue/student yr 5 | |||
| Transition cost | |||
| Lowest cash point | |||
| Programs kept/changed/closed | |||
| Biggest risk |
Phase 4: Decide, Pilot and Rebuild Once
By day 365, the college has chosen a direction, proven demand with real deposits and made its structural changes in a single funded round.
Step 1: The Board Decides (Day 120)
- Board reviews the three alternatives, red team report and independent advisor's view
- Board picks one alternative and records why
- Board funds the transition, including a reserve for the fallback
- Board names who is responsible for each part of execution
- Board confirms the stopping rules still hold
Step 2: Pilot with Real Deposits
A survey says what people would like. A deposit says what they will do.
| Who the pilot serves | |
| What the student gets | |
| Price after aid ($) | |
| Deposit amount ($) | |
| Deposit target (# students) | |
| Deadline for deposits | |
| Cost to run the pilot ($) | |
| Result that means EXPAND | |
| Result that means REVISE | |
| Result that means STOP |
Set the three results before the pilot opens. Do not change them after.
Step 3: Restructure Once
Make the foreseeable structural changes together, fund them fully and announce them clearly. Repeated small rounds of cuts keep everyone uncertain, hurt recruiting and use up trust.
- Which students the college will serve
- Which programs, schools and services stay, change or end
- Which costs actually disappear (cash the college stops spending)
- What the college will invest in, and how much
- How current students will finish, program by program
- How affected employees will be treated
- Contract, accreditation and regulatory steps
- Cost of running old and new programs side by side
- Space and administration the smaller college will need
Transition Budget
| Item | One-Time Cost ($) | Months | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Severance and benefits | |||
| Teach-out for current students | |||
| Contracts and leases to exit | |||
| Accreditation and regulatory work | |||
| Running old and new programs side by side | |||
| Launch of new offering | |||
| Reserve for fallback alternative | |||
| Total |
OPTIONAL APPENDIX — by Jeff Ritter
Appendix C: The Technology Layer
This appendix is a companion to the core workbook. A college that restructures its programs and governance but runs them on the same technology has solved half the problem. This section covers the other half — how AI and integrated systems can change the cost structure of the rebuilt college.
The Duolingo Ceiling
Duolingo teaches 100 million people a month with almost no human instructors. It is also, for most learners, a vocabulary drill. It works brilliantly for the structured, repetitive part of learning. It fails at the rest: holding a real conversation, understanding a poem, navigating a culture.
No amount of AI improvement fixes this, because the limitation is not the technology. It is the nature of the work.
AI handles the individual, repetitive, structured parts of learning very well and at very low cost. It does not handle judgment, meaning, relationship or surprise.
AI prepares the ground. Humans lead the learning that matters.
Practical example: An AI tool clusters student responses to a reading assignment before class. The professor sees that 40% misunderstood the central argument, 30% understood it but cannot apply it, and 30% are ready to move on. The professor walks in and teaches three different groups in one session. Without the tool, the professor lectures to the middle and hopes for the best. The AI did not teach. It made the teaching better.
Where AI Changes the Cost
| Work | AI Handles Well | AI Assists | AI Adds Little |
|---|---|---|---|
| Advising triage, scheduling, routine questions | ● | ||
| First-pass feedback on writing and problem sets | ● | ||
| Personalized study plans and practice | ● | ||
| Translation and accessibility | ● | ||
| Report generation, dashboards, compliance | ● | ||
| Curriculum mapping and outcome alignment | ● | ||
| Assessment design and rubric calibration | ● | ||
| Career exploration and job matching | ● | ||
| Enrollment prediction and financial modeling | ● | ||
| Mentoring, coaching, relationship-building | ● | ||
| Judging complex, ambiguous, creative work | ● | ||
| Leading discussion, debate, lab, clinical | ● | ||
| Crisis intervention, counseling, pastoral care | ● |
Read the left column as cost you can reduce. Read the right column as value you must protect.
Technology Audit
| System | What It Does | Annual Cost ($) | Contract Ends | AI Replace? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LMS (Canvas, Blackboard, etc.) | ||||
| SIS (student info system) | ||||
| ERP (finance, HR, facilities) | ||||
| CRM (enrollment, advancement) | ||||
| Assessment tools | ||||
| Advising platform | ||||
| Other | ||||
| Total Annual Technology Cost | ||||
What Faculty Fear and What to Do About It
- Name the ceiling. AI handles drill, practice and routine feedback. It does not handle what you do. We are investing in AI so that more of your time goes to the work only you can do.
- Start with tools that help faculty. An AI that clusters student responses before class makes the professor more effective. An AI that grades essays makes the professor feel watched. Start with the first kind.
- Let faculty choose their pace. The pilot should have early adopters who want to experiment, not a mandate. Adoption spreads through proof, not policy.
- Protect academic judgment. The professor decides the grade, designs the assignment, leads the class. AI prepares, sorts, drafts, and flags. The human decides.
- Show the math. If AI-assisted advising frees 200 staff hours a month, show faculty that those hours went to student support, not to a budget line that disappeared.
Campus OS: A Worked Example
What an AI-integrated campus operating system looks like when the pieces are designed as one system instead of twelve vendor platforms.
Instruction Engine
AI-powered personalized learning paths. Faculty set goals and judge outcomes.
Student Pulse
Real-time early alerts from attendance, grades, engagement and advising data.
Skill Map
Bayesian proficiency tracking — what a student actually knows, not just courses passed.
Entry Ticket
AI clusters student responses before class so the professor knows where everyone stands.
Advisor Hub
AI handles scheduling, routine questions, triage. Humans handle the conversations that matter.
Program Analytics
Contribution, enrollment trends and outcome data for every program on one screen.
Enrollment Intelligence
Predictive modeling for yield, retention and net revenue per student.
Operations Dashboard
Facilities, finance, HR and compliance in one view.
Community Bridge
Employer partnerships, internship matching, career exploration.
No college needs all nine on day one. Start with one or two modules during Phase 3 pilots and add others as the restructuring proceeds.
Technology does not save a college. A better offering for students who will pay for it saves a college. Technology makes that offering cheaper to deliver, better for the student, and possible to run with the smaller staff and budget the restructured college will have.
Appendices
A3 Thinking
An A3 is a single page that walks one idea from the facts to a plan. Two kinds matter here:
Problem A3
Question: Why is this measure falling short, and how do we fix it?
Time frame: Weeks to months
Example: First-year retention fell from 78 to 70 percent
Use when: The offering is right and something about delivery has slipped
Strategy A3
Question: Where should we go, and how will we prove it works?
Time frame: One to five years
Example: An evening degree for working adults in our region
Use when: The question is whether the offering itself is right
Treating a fit problem as a delivery problem. If several problem A3s point back to the same answer — people do not want this enough at this price — stop fixing and write a strategy A3.
A3 Review Questions
| Background | Is this tied to the gap, or is it a project someone already wanted? |
| Current state | Are these the same numbers the CFO uses? What is missing? |
| Target state | Is the target big enough to matter and specific enough to miss? |
| Gap analysis | Whose voice is this? Current students, or the people we need to attract? |
| Options | Was a cheaper option considered? Was "stop doing something" an option? |
| Test plan | Does the pilot ask for real money? Were the stop results set before launch? |
| Follow-up | Is one person accountable? Will the board see results on original targets? |
The Year at a Glance
| Day | Milestone | Lead | Owner | Done |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | President and CFO start Phase 1 | PRESCFO | ||
| 30 | One-page summary; rules and red team approved | PRESBOARD | ||
| 35 | Faculty and staff briefing; owners named | PRES | ||
| 40 | Student briefing; completion promise published | PRESCABINET | ||
| 60 | Demand brief and program fact sheets delivered | CABINETFACULTY | ||
| 75 | Idea card window closes; program review done | CABINET | ||
| 90 | A3 proposals drafted; student panel and donor map done | CABINETFACULTY | ||
| 100 | Transition cost estimate and space plan done | CABINET | ||
| 110 | CFO prices every surviving A3 and alternatives | CFO | ||
| 120 | Board chooses a direction and funds it | BOARD | ||
| 150 | Pilot opens for applications and deposits | CABINETFACULTY | ||
| 240 | Pilot deposit deadline; expand, revise or stop | PRESBOARD | ||
| 270 | Restructuring plan announced in one round | PRESBOARD | ||
| 365 | Annual review; run Phase 1 again | ALL |
Words to Know
A3
A one-page problem-solving format with seven boxes, used here to test each idea.
Contribution
What a program brings in minus the costs that go away without it.
Discount Rate
College-funded aid as a share of sticker tuition.
Red Team
A small group whose job is to show how a plan could fail.
Runway
Months of spendable cash at the current rate of loss.
Stopping Rule
A line set in advance that triggers a set action when crossed.
Teach-out
A plan that lets current students finish their degree when a program ends.